MSC Pre-assessment of Orange Roughy
In 2013, MSC pre-assessments of the four main orange roughy fisheries (ORH MEC, ORH3B ESCR, ORH3B NWCR and ORH7A) were undertaken by MRAG Americas. These updated the 2009 MSC pre-assessments and accounted for any changes since that time.
You can download MRAG's Pre-Assessment Report and all the documentation made public by Deepwater Group and the Ministry for Primary Industries during the assessment below.
Since then, three of these fisheries have proceeded to full MSC assessment (ORH3B ESCR, ORH3B NWCR and ORH7A). You can track their progress, here.
MRAG PRE-ASSESSMENT
principle 1
"A fishery must be conducted in a manner that does not lead to over-fishing or depletion of the exploited populations and, for those populations that are depleted, the fishery must be conducted in a manner that demonstrably leads to their recovery."
The intent of this principle is to ensure that the productive capacities of the resources are maintained at high levels and are not sacrificed in favour of short term interests.
DWG (2013) Briefing Note - ORH3B (NWR) Summary DWG (2011) ORH OEO OP v4 2011-12 Schedule 1 (insert) DWG (2011) ORH OEO OP v4 2011-12 DWG (2012) Memo re ORH OEO OP Schedule Update 2012-13 DWG (2012) ORH OEO OP v4 2012-13_Schedule 1 MPI (2006) Harvest Strategy Standard Discussion Document MPI (2008) Harvest Strategy Standard. MFish MPI (2010) 10 Year Research Programme for Deepwater Fisheries. Ministry of Fisheries. 148p MPI (2010) Final Advice Paper Sust_Measures_01_Oct_2010 MPI (2010) National Fishing Plan Deepwater and Middledepth Fisheries Part 1B - Orange Roughy MPI (2011) Annual Operational Plan for Deepwater Fisheries 2011-12 MPI (2011) Operational Guidelines for Harvest Strategy Standard (Review) MPI (2011) Operational Guidelines for Harvest Strategy Standard MPI (2011) Science Working Groups - Terms of Reference MPI (2012) Annual Operational Plan for Deepwater Fisheries 2012-13 MPI (2013) Annual Review Report -Deepwater-2011-12 MPI (2013) Fisheries Assessment Plenary - May 2013 - Volume 2 MPI (2013) Review of Management Controls for Orange Roughy 3B MPI (2014) Deepwater Research Planning Ryan & Kloser (2013) Biomass Estimation 2012 NW ChathamRise Anderson & Dunn (2012) Descriptive analysis of cpue in ORH to 2008–09 - FAR 2012-20 Anderson (2013) By-catch DW Fisheries - AEBR 113 Doonan & Dunn (2011) ORH MEC Trawl Survey - FAR 20 Doonan et al. (2012) orange-roughy-abundance-estimates - FAR 2012-28 Doonan et al. (2013) Comparison of ORH 7A age estimates between 1987 and 2009 - FAR 2013 2 Dunn et al. (2009) Nursery Grounds of the Orange Roughy around NZ. ICES J. Mar. Sci. 66. 871-85 "Fishing operations should allow for the maintenance of the structure, productivity, function and diversity of the ecosystem (including habitat and associated dependent and ecologically related species) on which the fishery depends." The intent of this principle is to encourage management of fisheries from an ecosystem perspective under a system designed to restrain the impacts of the fishery on the ecosystem. Boyd (2013) Appendix 1 ORH AEEF Report August 2013 Boyd (2013) Appendix 2 ORH AEEF Report August 2013 Boyd (2013) Appendix 3 ORH AEEF Report August 2013 MPI (2012) Aquatic Environment and Biodiversity Annual Review DWG & MPI (2013) ORH Fishery Observer Programme Report ORH AEEF Retained & Bycatch Component Information - Aug 2013 Ramm (2010) CSP Observer Report 2008-09 Ramm (2012a) CSP Observer Report 2009-10 Ramm (2012b) CSP Observer Report 2010-11 Rowe (2009) CSP Observer Report 2006-07 Rowe (2010a) CSP Observer Report 2007-08 Anderson (2011) ORH By-catch & Discards - AEBR 67 Anderson (2013) By-catch DW Fisheries - AEBR 113 Blackwell (2010) Abundance Distribution of DW Sharks - AEBR 57 MacGibbon (2013) Alfonsiono MEC - FAR 30 MPI (2013) Fisheries Assessment Plenary - May 2013 - Volume 1 MPI (2013) Fisheries Assessment Plenary - May 2013 - Volume 2 MPI (2013) Fisheries Assessment Plenary - May 2013 - Volume 3 MPI. (2010). Introduction of Patagonian Toothfish into QMS O'Driscoll et al. (2011) Chatham Rise 1992-2010 FAR 47 O'Driscoll_11_47_Species AGR to CCX O'Driscoll_11_47 Species CDL to CYP O'Driscoll_11_47 Species DCO to FRS O'Driscoll_11_47 Species GAS to HTH O'Driscoll_11_47 Species JAV to LSO O'Driscoll_11_47 Species MAK to ORH O'Driscoll_11_47 Species PDG to RUD O'Driscoll_11_47 Species SAL to SOR O'Driscoll_11_47 Species SPD to SWA O'Driscoll_11_47 Species TAR to WWA Stevens et al (2010) Rattails Age Growth Maturity AEBR 59 Tracey et al (2011) Deepsea Fish Distribution Seamounts Anderson et al (1998) Atlas of Fish Distributions Doonan & Dunn (2011) ORH MEC Trawl Survey - FAR 20 Dunn et al (2010) Diet of DW Sharks Gallagher et al (2012) ERA for Elasmobranchs ORH AEEF Protected Species Component - Aug 2013 Thompson and Berkenbusch (2013) Protected species bycatch in ORH - 2002-... Ramm (2010) CSP Observer Report 2008-09 Ramm (2012a) CSP Observer Report 2009-10 Ramm (2012b) CSP Observer Report 2010-11 Rowe (2009) CSP Observer Report 2006-07 Rowe (2010a) CSP Observer Report 2007-08 Baird and Clark (2013) Coral Distribution and ORH Fisheries Baird et al (2012) Distribution of Protected Corals in New Zealand Consalvey et al (2006) Protected Coral Information Review Miller et al (2009) Advances in Deep Sea Coral Science Sherwood & Edinger (2009) Age & Growth of Deepsea Corals Tracey et al (2007a) Age & Growth of Corals Tracey et al (2011a) Distribution of Corals in relation to fishing Tracey et al (2011b) habitat forming Corals Frances & Sutton (2012) Basking Shark By-catch Review Francis & Lyon (2012) Protected Fishes Review Francis & Smith (2010) Basking Shark By-catch 2007-08 - AEBR 49 Thompson et al (2013) Marine Mammals Captures 1995-96 to 2010-11 - AEBR 105 Fisheries Commercial Fishing Regulations 2001 MPI (2011) Draft Seabirds Policy for addressing fishing related mortality of Seabirds. Richard & Abraham (2011) Seabird Risk Assessment Richard & Abraham (2013a) Seabird Risk Assessment AEBR 109 - Supplementary Richard & Abraham (2013b) Seabird Risk Assessment AEBR 109 Richard & Abraham (2013c) Seabird PBR - AEBR 108 Rowe (2010b) Level 1 Seabird Risk Assessment Thompson and Berkenbusch (2013) Protected species bycatch in ORH - 2002-... Abraham & Thompson (2011) ETP Captures 2008-09 - AEBR 80 Abraham et al (2010) ETP Captures 2007-08 Abraham & Thompson (2011) Seabird Captures 2008-09 - AEBR 79 Abraham et al (2010) ETP Captures 2007-08 Baird (2008) Net Captures of Seabirds Baker et al (2009) NZ Fur Seal Census - Draft V2 Thompson & Abraham (2009) New Zealand Sea Lions 2006-07 Thompson et al (2010a) New Zealand Sea Lions 2007-08 Thompson et al (2010b) New Zealand Fur Seals Baird and Clark (2013) Coral Distribution and ORH Fisheries Baird et al (2012) Distribution of Corals Black et al (2013) DeepwaterTrawl Footprint - AEBR 110 Bowden (2010) Benthic Inverterbrate samples from Ocean survey 2020 CRCP AEBR 65 Clark (2013) Information on the Structure and Function of UTF habitats Floerl et al (2011) Benthic Patterns Chatham Challenger - AEBR 97 Hewitt et al (2011a) Biotic Habitats Chatham Challenger - AEBR 81 MPI (2012) Aquatic Environment and Biodiversity Annual Review Nodder et al (2011) Physical biogeochemical and microbia characteristics Chatham Rise - AEBR 70 ODriscoll & Clark (2005) Fishing on NZ Seamounts ORH AEEF Habitat Component Information - Aug 2013 Stewart (2013) ORH Trawl Footprint GNS Science 2013-190LR 190813 Tilney (2013) Summary of ORH Fishery Trawl Footprint 160813 Tracey et al. (2011) Identification of Protected Corals UNESCO (2009) GOODS Biogeographic Classification-IOC Technical Series No 84 Althaus et al (2009) Seamounts & Corals Clark et al (2010) Effects Fishing Graveyard Complex - AEBR 46 Clark et al (2011) Development of seamount risk assessment - AEBR 74 Dunn & Forman (2011) Stock Structure in ORH Jennings et al (2001) Impact sof trawling disturbance Kaiser et al (2006) Benthic Recovery Leathwick et al (2012) BOMEC - AEBR 88 Mormede & Dunn (2013) Benthic Impacts - AEBR 106 MPI (2011) Aquatic Environment and Biodiversity Annual Review Rice (2006) Impacts of Mobile Bottom Gear on Habitats Rosenberg (2001) Benthic Succession Rowden & Clark (2010) Seamount Biodiversity in Kermadec - AEBR 62 Rowden et al (2002) Seamount Biodiversity Rowden et al (2005) Classification of Seamounts Rowden et al (2008) Seamount Database - AEBR 27 Rowden et al (2012) Marine Soft Sediment Assemblages - AEBR 96 Tracey et al (2011) Deepsea Fish Distribution Seamounts Doonan & Dunn (2011) Trawl survey of Mid-East Coast orange roughy 2010-11 Dunn & Forman (2010) Hypotheses of Spatial Stock Structure in Orange Roughy Dunn (2013) Ecosystem Impacts of Orange Roughy Fisheries [Unpublished] Dunn et al (2013)Knight et al (2011) ORH AEEF Ecosystem Component Information- Aug 2013 Boyd (2013) Appendix 1 ORH AEEF Report August 2013 Boyd (2013) Appendix 2 ORH AEEF Report August 2013 Boyd (2013) Appendix 3 ORH AEEF Report August 2013 ORH AEEF August 2013 - Methodology Final Bradford-Grieve & Livingston (Eds) (2011) WCSI-Productivity Clark et al (2000) The effects of commercial exploitation on orange roughy Dunn et al (2009) Fish abundance and climate trends AEBR 31 Dunn et al (2009) Nursery grounds of the orange roughy around New Zealand Garrison & Link (2000) Fishing Effectson Trophic Guild Structure "The fishery is subject to an effective management system that respects local, national and international laws and standards and incorporates institutional and operational frameworks that require use of the resource to be responsible and sustainable." The intent of this principle is to ensure that there is an institutional and operational framework for implementing Principles 1 and 2, appropriate to the size and scare of the fishery. Benthic Protection Areas Regulations 2007 DOC (2013) Conservation Services Programme Annual Plan 2013-14 DWG (2011) Marine Mammals Operational Procedures v7 2011-12 DWG (2011) Reporting Operational Procedures v5 2011-12 DWG MFISH (2010) Partnership Agreement Fisheries_Commercial_Fishing_Amendment_Regulations_2009 Fisheries_Commercial_Fishing_Regulations_2001 Fisheries_Reporting_Regulations_2001 Fisheries_Satellite_Vessel_Monitoring_Regulations_1993 Kazmierow et al (2010) Commercial Fishers Compliance Decision Making Lock & Leslie (2007) New Zealand's Quota Management System - A History of the First 20 Years MPI (2006) Harvest Strategy Standard Discussion Document MPI (2008) FAP - Indentification of Candidate Stocks for QMS Introduction MPI (2008) Fisheries 2030 - Report by PWC MPI (2008) Harvest Strategy Standard. MFish MPI (2008) QMS Introduction Process Standard - Exec Summary MPI (2008) Review of Sustainability Measures and Other Management Measures MPI (2009) Compliance Information Sheet 01 MPI (2009) Compliance Information Sheet 02 MPI (2009) Stakeholder Consultation Process Standard. Ministry of Fisheries MPI (2010) 10 Year Research Programme for Deepwater Fisheries. Ministry of Fisheries. 148p MPI (2010) Compliance Information Sheet 03 MPI (2010) Compliance Information Sheet 04 MPI (2010) Compliance Information Sheet 05 MPI (2010) Compliance Information Sheet 06 MPI (2010) Compliance Information Sheet 07 MPI (2010) Final Advice Paper - Review of Sustainability Measures (01 Oct 2010) MPI (2010) National Fishing Plan Deepwater and Middledepth Fisheries Part 1A MPI (2010) National Fishing Plan Deepwater and Middledepth Fisheries Part 1B - Orange Roughy MPI (2010) Statement of Intent. Minstry of Fisheries MPI (2011) Annual Operational Plan for Deepwater Fisheries 2011-12 MPI (2011) Operational Guidelines for Harvest Strategy Standard (Review) MPI (2011) Operational Guidelines for Harvest Strategy Standard MPI (2012) Annual Operational Plan for Deepwater Fisheries 2012-13 MPI (2013) Annual Review Report -Deepwater-2011-12 MPI (2013) Fisheries Observer Tables 2010-11 & 2011-12 MPI (2013) Review of Management Controls for Orange Roughy 3B
Supplementary Documents
Principle 2
1 & 2. Retained and Bycatch Component
Conservation Service Programme
Retained and Bycatch Species Information
Supplementary Documents
3. ETP Component
Conservation Service Programme
Corals
ETP Sharks and Fishes
Marine Mammals
Seabirds
Supplementary Documents
4. Habitat Component
Supplementary Documents
5. Ecosystem Component
ORH AEEF Methodology
Supplementary Documents
Principle 3